The Mining Remediation Authority (MRA) has stated that it does not consider coal tip extraction to be a ‘coal mining operation’ because it claims that coal tip extraction does not meet any of the requirements listed within the s.65(1) of the 1994 Act definition of a ‘coal mining operation’ or a ‘coal mine’. As a result, the MRA states that it has no power to licence or not licence mining a coal tip. And DESNZ adds that it does not plan to make any changes so that coal tip mining projects would require a licence from the MRA in future (based on the understanding it is not currently required, which is against our Barristers’ understanding).

This boils down to a difference in interpreting some heavyweight law that’s over 30 years old. Some of the argument hinges on whether you read a sentence such as “to be a thing, it must include the following: X, Y, ‘and’ Z” to mean it needs to be all of X,Y,Z to be the thing, or it’s enough for it just to be Y, for example. The only way to settle the argument is a costly court case with our Barristers on one side and UK Government Barristers on the other side – and the UK Government has much deeper pockets than us.

The civil servants within the UK Government are right now busy cooking up new legislation to ban the MRA from issuing any new licences for coal mining – which is great news because all coal mining needs a licence…so that means no new coal mining projects (existing licences can still be used). The problem is that it won’t ban mining coal tips, because of the MRA’s belief that this doesn’t require a licence in the first place. That means, once this new legislation passes, the only place coal can be mined in the UK is coal tips – which will still be fair game, undermining the intention of the coal ban to stop coal mining.

This is a particularly absurd situation as mining previously discarded coal from coal tips or mining new coal from opencast coal mines involves the same processes – moving large volumes of soil around with HGVs, separating spoil from saleable coal, transporting that coal etc. and generating the same local environmental and community impacts such as noise, dust, and disruption. It will also have the same climate change effects when burned. Mining coal tips is an industry that dates back until at least the 1980s. With over 5,000 coal tips around the UK and a live proposal to mine two coal tips in South Wales of over 400,000 tonnes of coal, we begin to understand why it matters whether coal tips are included within the new legislation to ban coal mining.

PLAN A
The easiest option would be for the civil servants beavering away at the new coal ban legislation to simply include an amendment requiring coal tips to need a licence (via clarification or change to existing legislation). This would bring coal tip mining, opencast mining, and deep mining all within the same requirement for a licence – which the new legislation would then ban in one swoop. Find out more about the simple legal wording our Barristers have suggested including to do this.

PLAN B
If Ministers and civil servants refuse to explicitly include coal tips within the new legislation, we are going to have to consider a legal challenge to the UK Government’s belief that mining coal tip doesn’t need a licence. If we win that, then mining coal tips would be banned within the new legislation by default. We hope you’ll support our fundraising efforts if we are forced to do that.