BACK TO TOP

Tip closest to residents to remain untouched

Clearing up the confusion

This information seeks to clarify which tips are included in ERI Ltd's proposal to mine and then flatten certain coal tips in Caerphilly. The tips selected appear to be on the basis of which would be most profitable to mine of the 'waste coal' they contain, rather than which most endanger residents. This is not surprising as the proposal is being brought by a for-profit mining company, but it does differ from how the company is presenting itself as an expert in remediation rather than mining.

Tip closest to Trethomas residents would remain untouched

Tip 90319 that most concerns residents is closest to them - it backs onto the gardens of some residents. It's also a site with concerns surrounding possibly toxic elements contained within the tip. Due to its proximity to residents, it's also seen a higher proportion of intentionally set fires that the fire service has been called out for compared to the other tips sited further away. There are also more tangible signs of the tip's industrial past and ongoing monitoring than the other, more naturalised tips. If the priority was to remediate the coal tips, this tip would be prioritised. Instead, this tip has been excluded from ERI Ltd's proposal to mine coal tips, with the promise to use some of those profits to then flatten the coal tips and remediate the area.

Nature returning and reclaiming tip 90319

Despite the concerns around toxic elements in tip 90319 and the visible industrial heritage of the site, there are signs of nature slowly returning to the area. It's vital that any measures to remediate this coal tip - or any others - in future take full stock of the nature that has regrown. If there are legitimate safety risks, though, this must be prioritised.

Published: 08. 05. 2025

Share now:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Never miss an update! Sign up to our Newsletter

OTHER STORIES

King’s Speech Summary: Support for coal tip mining ban

Earlier this month, the King’s Speech marked a major milestone for our campaign for the introduction of legislation which will ban new coal mines. The Government formally announced the Energy Independence Bill, and with it a commitment to ‘Implement the manifesto commitment to end new coal licenses’. This is a breakthrough…

World leading standards for operational and legacy industrial emissions

During their party conference, Plaid Cymru announced plans for their first hundred days of Government, should they win the Welsh election. Having now formed the Government, we hope to work with them and other Members of the Senedd to achieve some of those priorities. This is the last of three posts outlining opportunities which could help them to do that…

Opencast vs deep coal mines

Deep coal mines have a long history in the UK dating back some 400 years. On the other hand, opencast coal mines only became common between 1940 and 60, becoming the dominant mining method in the UK as deep coal mining entered rapid decline. Opencast coal mining techniques…

Welsh parties commit to restoration ahead of elections

We worked with media outlet, Nation.Cymru, to ask where the main political parties in Wales stands on restoration issues ahead of the Welsh election on 07th May 2026. This is a key issue for many people, but particularly those who live near under-restored opencast coal mine sites…

Ben Hodge-McKenna on reopening Welsh coal mines

As part of our Politics Unspun series we are unpacking politicians’ public comments on coal to challenge any misleading or incorrect messages. Todays’ focus is on comments made in a BBC interview during the Senedd election campaign about coal mining in Wales. During the interview, Reform UK candidate in Afan Ogwr Rhondda, Ben Hodge-McKenna…

Our 2026 Wales manifesto

Coal Action Network is proud to present our 2026 manifesto for Wales. With the Senedd elections taking place in May this year, Wales stands at a decisive moment. For over a century, coal has shaped Welsh landscapes, communities, and politics. Today, Wales has the opportunity to shape something very different…

Lee Anderson on dirty, horrible, dangerous coal jobs

As part of our Politics Unspun series we are unpacking politicians’ public comments on coal to challenge any misleading or incorrect messages. Todays’ focus is on comments made during a Westminster Hall debate in December 2025 about the oil refining sector. During the debate, Lee Anderson MP made some statements about coal…

Take Action – End new English coal

The Government is reforming planning policy in England and thanks to thousands of our supporters asking for an end to coal extraction in the last consultation in 2024, they are now recommending that planners “should not identify new sites or extensions to existing sites for peat or coal extraction”…

Demand nature be restored to Ffos-y-fran opencast site

Merthyr (South Wales) Ltd mined for over a year illegally after planning permission for the Ffos-y-fran opencast coal mine ended in September 2022. During that year, it made record-breaking profits due to sanctions on Russia and other factors driving up the price of coal. But rather than using some of the profits from that ill-gotten coal…

CONNECT WITH US

Share now: